skip to Main Content

Historic Irish Hill Home | Online Auction

BIDDING BEGINS

2:00 PM
Thursday, February 26  2026

BIDDING ENDS

2:00 PM *
Thursday, March 19  2026

*Extended Bidding
ADDRESS

1238 Payne Street
Louisville, KY 40204

JUMP TO

Download Our App for Easy Bidding
iPhone  |  Android

Buyer's Premium

10% Buyer’s Premium added to the hammer bid price to determine the final purchase price.

Real Estate Terms

A non-refundable down payment, 10% of the Purchase Price (Final Bid + Buyer’s Premium), in the form of cash, check, or wired funds in USD are due within 24 hours following the auction, balance due in 40 days. Buyer to receive clear title. Taxes prorated to the day of closing. Selling as is without contingencies, all inspections welcomed prior to auction. If you choose to obtain financing, not subject to approval or appraisal. All closing costs are the buyer’s expense. Possession at closing. See full details in the Auction Bid Packet.

Reserve

Sells Subject to Seller Confirmation

Open House

  • Tuesday, March 10, 11:00 AM – 1:00 PM
  • Thursday, March 19, 11:00 AM – 1:00 PM

Or contact us for a private showing.

Seller

Susan M. Rademaker
Angela R. Henderson

Documents

Opportunity knocks in the heart of Irish Hill, one of Louisville’s most beloved historic neighborhoods. Just minutes from the vibrant restaurants, boutiques, and energy of the nearby Highlands district – and adjacent to the expansive Cave Hill Cemetery – this circa-1890 brick two-story home includes a detached garage with both Pine Street and alley access, offering incredible potential. Formerly configured as a duplex, this 2,012 square foot residence is ready for renovation and restoration. Easy access to I-64 off Story Avenue exit – located between Baxter Avenue and Lexington Road.

PROPERTY HIGHLIGHTS

  • Circa 1890 Brick Two-Story Home
  • 2,012 Square Feet | Two Floors
  • Seven Rooms | Two Full Baths
  • Previously Configured as Duplex
  • Fenced Corner Lot (27’ x 140’)
  • Detached Garage with both Pine Street & Brick Alley Access
  • Historic Irish Hill Neighborhood
  • Located between Lexington Road & Baxter Avenue
  • 1.4 Miles from I-64 Story Avenue Exit

HOME DETAILS

With 2,012 square feet, seven rooms, and a former duplex layout, the possibilities are wide open. Design a bold single-family showpiece, create an income-producing duplex, blend the historic charm with modern industrial style. The fenced corner lot offers flexibility, complete with detached garage with both side street and alley access – perfect for off-street parking, a workshop, or future expansion. An above-ground pool is included on site, sold as-is.

  • 1,162 SF Main Level | 850 SF Upper Level
  • 7 Rooms | 2 Baths | Laundry Closet
  • Wood Floors
  • Average 9’ Ceiling Height
  • Four Period Fireplace Mantels (Non-Operational)
  • Goodman High Efficiency Gas Furnace (Main Level)
  • Gas Space Heaters (Upper Level)
  • Cellar (9 X 10) With Concrete Floor (Hatch Door Access In Bathroom)
  • Covered Front Porch

DETACHED ONE-CAR GARAGE

  • 22.2 X 20.2
  • Traditional-Style Wood Swing Doors
  • Concrete Floor
  • Corner Of Pine Street And Brick Alley
  • Off Street Parking

ABOUT IRISH HILL

Originally known as Billy Goat Hill, Irish Hill developed in the mid-1800s as a settlement for Irish and German Catholic families. During the historic 1937 flood, the hill served as a refuge for thousands fleeing rising waters downtown.

The neighborhood is rich with historic landmarks, including:

  • Breslin Park, located at the former City Workhouse site
  • Distillery Commons, once home to the Old Kentucky Distillery
  • The former St. Aloysius Catholic Church (circa 1890-1996)
  • The historic Rogers Street Firehouse

Today, Irish Hill is bounded by Baxter Avenue, Lexington Road, Beargrass Creek, and I-64 – placing it in one of Louisville’s most historically layered and increasingly desirable areas.

LG&E (2 Gas & 2 Electric Meters)
Louisville Water Company (1 Meter)
Louisville MSD

2025 – Jefferson County, KY
Annual Gross Base Amount — $2,604.04

FEMA records indicate that the property is not in a flood zone.

Lot Size: 27’ x 140’
Deed Book 12406 | Page 183
Parcel: 068G00840000

Jefferson County

Directions

I-64 Story Avenue Exit to Baxter Avenue to Payne Street. Also accessible via Lexington Road.

TIPS TO HELP YOU WIN!

We know that the end of an online auction can be a hectic place. Here are some tips & things you should know to help make it a little easier…

MAX BID

Place your max bid and let the system bid for you. In the event two bidders have placed identical max bids, the first bid received will be the successful bid.

EXTENDED BIDDING

To prevent bid sniping, last-minute bids will extend individual lots using our ‘soft-close’ functionality.

  • If a bid is placed in the last 10 minutes, the lot will remain open for an additional 10 minutes.
  • If any further bidding occurs, the extension timer will reset to 10 minutes.
  • If no further bidding occurs, the lot closes when the timer runs out.
Back To Top